The full title of the book includes the words “A Most Peculiar Malaysian Murder” and  murder is definitely outside of the norm as murders go.

Inspector Singh is something of an annoyance to his superiors and his comrades in the Singapore police.  He is opinionated, stubborn, and somewhat disrespectful of authority (insofar as anyone can be disrespectful of authority in Singapore) so when it is learned that a woman from the city-state is accused of murder in Kuala Lumpur, it makes sense to send Singh to a place where he can annoy others for awhile.

The woman destined to be on death row is Chelsea Liew, a former model with one of the most recognizable faces in southeast Asia.  She is accused of killing her husband, Alan Lee, a man no one was going to miss.  Alan Lee was the director of the family timber business, a highly successful family enterprise that had made the family very wealthy.  Alan and Chelsea had married in a highly publicized ceremony that had conferred the status of royalty on the couple.  But, behind closed doors, Alan was guilty of spousal abuse, he was a philanderer, and he was involved in a number of nefarious business schemes that did nothing to enhance the name of Lee in Malay society.

When Chelsea decides to divorce Alan, she isn’t prepared for the degree to which he will go to ensure that he gets sole custody of their sons.  He converts to Islam and declares his children to be Muslims as well, guaranteeing that Chelsea will have no contact with them.

Alan dies at the hands of someone who knew him well enough to get past his bodyguards.  After publicly swearing that she would kill him for taking her children, Chelsea is the immediate front runner in the “who killed Alan Lee” stakes but there are other contenders.  Alan’s older brother, Jasper, the heir to the business, has walked away from it to pursue his commitment to protect the ecology of the country and has watched his brother ignore the policies that the Lee family have in place to protect the forests which are the source of their wealth.  The younger son, Kian Min, has plans to go further in expanding the family timber company no matter what the cost and the first item of business is to get rid of Alan.  Chelsea insists that she is innocent but the police are convinced of her guilt and see no need to look further.

INSPECTOR SINGH INVESTIGATES is a story of marital disaster, family breakdown, greed, jealousy, misguided  commitments, and shattered loyalty.  The Lee family are starring in their own soap opera with Inspector Singh in the wings watching the drama, looking for the person who goes off script.

The book is a fast read and most of the violence is kept off the page.  Unfortunately, the intriguing things about the locales, Kuala Lumpur and Singapore, are also kept off the page.  The story could take place in any major city in nearly any part of the world.  There is nothing of the sense of place that is found in Cotterill’s Laos, Qiu’s Shanghai, or Hallinan’s Bangkok.  Malaysia is confined to the cover art.

That being said, I will probably read other books in the series as they become available.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to INSPECTOR SINGH INVESTIGATES – Shamini Flint

  1. Dorte H says:

    You are reading so many of the books I have read or am going to read soon right now. We seem to like many of the same authors. I have not read this one yet, though, but it is on my TBR for the global reading challenge.

  2. kathy d. says:

    I found a little bit of Malaysia in the book, but it sent me to Google all sorts of related items, as the peoples of that country.
    The author said that she read the national security laws so that she would not find herself at odd with the Malaysian or Singaporean governments, with anything she said, so she was being cautious.
    I found this fun, and interesting on the parts about the forests and its peoples being destroyed by timber industries.
    I will try to read more in this series.

  3. Beth says:

    Kathy, I was disappointed that there were not parts of the book that were distinctly Malaysian. Sharia law versus civil law is already a problem in some countries in Europe.


  4. nylusmilk says:

    i’ve just read this. the first thought after finishing it was that there was nothing peculiar about the murder at all. the cops arrested two people for murder but it was not mentioned what proof they had to detain them. and inspector singh didn’t even discover the whodunit. now that i think about it, i don’t even recall who killed the first person murdered in the book.

    the dialogue tries to imitate the malaysian way of speaking english at times but it usually ends up sounding unnatural to me as a malaysian. i find that the story does not move at a gripping pace and it was a chore to complete it. personally, a disappointing read.

  5. Beth says:

    nylusmilk – When I decided to read the book, it was because I assumed Malaysia and its culture would be prominent. As I mentioned, other writers are brilliant at creating their settings, the place of the book, that the characters are clearly a product of that culture.

    As a Malaysian, you recognize the flaws. I think most people who read the book will not have had an opportunity to spend time in the country. Since it is a first book in a series, most reviewers will likely give the author the benefit of the doubt and read the second in the series to discover if the author has tightened up on the parts that don’t ring true.

    Have you contacted the publisher or the author with your concerns about the book? The author may appreciate some constructive criticism.

    Thank for posting. Please come back and comment on any of the other books on the site that you have read.

  6. Pingback: AUTHORS E – H (A Long List) | MURDER by TYPE

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s